Welcome Guest

Pages: 1
Track Year and Album Year
FlamFlingerPostJanuary 23, 2021, 11:41
Newbie
Posts: 2
Registered:
January 23, 2021, 16:19
Normal topicTrack Year and Album Year

Hello!
long time-ish Yate user, first time post (TTBOMK...)

This is about the year box when entering metadata for some ripped CDs or iTunes albums.

As I understand it, in this example of Various Artists (Million Selling Artists), Each song on the CD will have the release year of the song in the YEAR box. But if I want to give a year for album release it goes in a different box. Is that box one of these, RELEASE TIME or ORIGINAL RELEASE TIME?

And, second question, I wondered why these aren't called TRACK YEAR, ALBUM YEAR?

Many thanks!

2MR2PostJanuary 23, 2021, 12:05
Avatar photo
Administrator
Posts: 2084
Registered:
August 23, 2012, 19:27
Normal topicTrack Year and Album Year

The release date fields are typically associated with albums. Yate's slew of fields was initially modelled after the ID3 specification as it was and still is the most well defined specification available.

Year is typically used to represent the YYYY component of the release date and is the most common field actually used by players. This is simply by convention as that's how most players historically treated the field. Certainly this is how iTunes treats it. Yate lets you get around the limiting to YYYY restriction as many users like keeping the entire release date in it. At the low level, Year in ID3 based files is mapped to a TDRC frame which is defined as the 'Recording time'. Virtually no players treat this field as the recording time.

The 'Release Time' field is defined as the name implies. Not too many players actually read this field. Many users store a somewhat full release date here: ie. YY-MM-DD

The 'Original Release Time' field as defined in the ID3 specification is supposed to be the time when the original recording of the audio was released. However, many users store the time the track was originally released by the artist ... which is not necessarily the same.

This is all pretty confusing and is a result of the almost complete lack of standards.

The bottom line is that it's your media and you should tag it any way to want as long as it satisfies your player of choice. If your player is iTunes, it only cares about the Year field so you can pretty much do it however you wish.

Personally I tag my Various Artist releases as follows: Year contains the date the compilation was released. Original Release Time contains the date the track was released. Simply my method 🙂

Pages: 1
Mingle Forum by Cartpauj | Version: 1.1.0beta | Page loaded in: 0.013 seconds.