Quote from rh2021 on April 16, 2022, 01:38
I also use Yate with Roon. Using a .tsv file to update Yate information, I have found that the following original release date format (in the tsv file) works well:
19-January-2000
The advantage of altering the original release date is that this is the field (file tag) that Roon uses as a secondary sort. When sorting albums by Artist, Roon uses sort album artist name then original release date. All my classical albums have customised 'original release dates' corresponding to their album title so the secondary sort mimics album titles.
I have to jump through a couple of hoops with Roon (don't we all?) to get it to do what I want, but basically, for classical box sets, I like them all to arrange in the numbered order of the box set itself, so the "album artist" & "original release date" fields all need to be the same, so that the numbering in "album title" forces the order.
For this reason, I would use the original release date of the box set, not the individual albums.
As I mentioned above, I've found that if I add, say, 2011-11-15 to Yate's "Original Release Time" slot in "More Info" it will drop neatly into the "user data" slot in Roon (& I have Roon set to prefer all my tags).
If the "Release Date" is different, it will show up as a separate date in the info underneath the album title, but now I know that I can expand the date field in Yate, I can put the same information there & it cleans out that duplicate entry because if they're the same, Roon only shows in once. Which is nice.
That, for me, is a very quick & easy way to get a big box set into the right order.
If I have other information available, I can then go through disc by disc & change "Release Date" to the actual release date of the individual album & start & end dates to the Recording dates.
It would be really good to know exactly what things Roon would respond to if I were to add them as UD entries in Yate, but I'm not sure the people at Roon really give a monkey's about making my tagging easy, as what they really want me to do is to identify all the albums, drink the Kool Aid & let Roon's "richness" wash over me.
Doing the above would mean that, were my database to become corrupted, all the correct info would be in my files & nothing would need re-doing, but I fear that might never be possible.
(Probably also worth mentioning that I'm a bit weird in that I like all the albums to show next to each other in Roon, not as a single multi-disc entry, so I also "undo" all of that functionality with my folder naming.)
|